Skip to content

Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

“A banter-driven crew and relentless set pieces dazzle, while sponge gunplay and endless spawns keep the verdict split.”

A lost fleet hunt opens on a Borneo dig and runs through a war-torn Nepalese city toward the road to Shambhala. A partner betrayal and a war criminal’s chase for a fabled stone drive the pursuit, with shifting crew loyalties complicating every alliance. Quippy cinematic tone binds the trail, loaded with cutscenes and banter between climbs and firefights. Supernatural guardians stalk the late chapters, and a stone revelation waits in deliberate vagueness. Blockbuster momentum carries the expedition from the first dig to the final gauntlet.

Climbing and cover shooting alternate as the core loop, with stealth attempts softening entries and light puzzles breaking the rhythm. Mirror-light temples, statue-arm alignments and cylinder symbols resolve quickly, offering breather beats rather than resistance. The FAL answers patrols better than the AK, with grenade arcs covering clusters and crossbows arriving late. Museum heists, Borneo camps, Nepal rooftops, train sequences, mountain caves and monastery stealth stack spectacle chapters in quick succession. Tower gate puzzles and a guardian gauntlet close the progression with trials under fire. Stealth entries reward patience before alarms collapse the option into open firefights.

Crew banter does the heavy lifting, with a thief, a mentor, a journalist and a rival trading quips through every frustration. Shifting loyalties among the crew keep alliances fluid across betrayals and reunions. Betrayal gives the hunt its sting, turning a partner’s treachery into the campaign’s sharpest personal turn. Cutscene density runs high, trading control for cinema at regular intervals. Characters carry the whole game where mechanics stumble.

Train sequences stage the signature set piece, with a wounded climb up a hanging carriage opening the campaign. Collapsing hotels drop floors mid-firefight while rooftop chases sprint across a war-torn skyline. Museum heists open the campaign with stealth and precision before Borneo camps widen the combat. Monastery stealth and tower gate puzzles vary the approach before mountain caves narrow it again. Guardian gauntlets and a war-criminal boss fight close the spectacle with bullet-eating dread.

Enemy ranks escalate from patrols to riot shields, heavies, RPGs, tanks and bullet-eating guardians. Sponge flesh absorbs absurd punishment while return fire kills fast, draining firefights of fairness. Endless spawns refill cleared rooms, with one Shambhala chamber crossing into pure excess. Tank slogs and demon-guardian returns mark the friction peaks. Balance stays the weakest register from monastery to finale. Riot shields and heavies demand flanking, punishing frontal assaults with quick deaths.

Whiffed jumps and cover-versus-roll mixups turn traversal and escapes into gambles. Grab detection compounds the problem at the worst vertical moments. Puzzles entertain but stay far too few, resolving quickly with little following. Cover-versus-roll mixups misfire under pressure, rolling past safety into open fire. Upscaling ghosting shimmers on characters, with no crashes across the full campaign. Minor presentation friction never interrupts the blockbuster clip.

Set-piece density over mechanical depth defines the identity: a cinematic interactive-movie shooter rather than a systems showcase. Story and characters win where puzzles and gunplay lose, and the campaign never pretends otherwise. Normal difficulty keeps the spectacle accessible while sponge and spawn friction persist. Banter-driven momentum compensates for basic shooting across the campaign. The expedition charms as cinema and frustrates as a shooter in equal measure. Guardian dread gives the back half a darker register the front half never reaches.

Overall, top-tier crew banter and relentless blockbuster set-piece spectacle share the frame with sponge gunplay, endless spawns and fussy traversal. Neither half yields; the characters redeem stretches the mechanics squander.